Stablecoins: how they hold their peg, and how a peg breaks
Financial disclaimer, not financial advice. This article is general information and education only. It does not recommend buying, selling, or holding any crypto asset, fund, or product, and it is not personalised financial, tax, or legal advice. Crypto assets are volatile and speculative and can lose all of their value. Consider your own circumstances and, where appropriate, speak with a qualified professional in your jurisdiction before making any financial decision.
A stablecoin is a token designed to trade at a fixed price, most often one U.S. dollar. The design is easy to state and easy to misunderstand, because the fixed price is not built into the token. Nothing inside a token forces a market to pay a dollar for it. The price holds, when it holds, because three separate things are working at once: assets held in reserve, a redemption route that turns tokens back into the pegged currency, and traders with a profit motive to correct small deviations. Remove any one of the three and the word “stable” becomes a description of the past, not a property of the coin.
Fiat-backed coins: reserves, redemption, arbitrage
The dominant model is the plainest. An issuer takes in dollars and issues tokens; the dollars, or assets very close to them, sit in reserve. Circle, the issuer of USDC, describes a reserve built around cash and short-dated U.S. Treasuries, much of it held through the Circle Reserve Fund, a registered government money market fund managed by BlackRock and custodied at Bank of New York Mellon, available only to Circle. Circle also states that the fund shares and cash are held in separate accounts from the rest of its business, and that its reserve decisions are designed so that USDC is always redeemable one-for-one for U.S. dollars.
Redemption is the hinge. When an eligible holder can hand a token back to the issuer and receive a dollar, the token has a floor built out of something other than hope. Arbitrage does the daily work on top of that floor. As market explainers describe the mechanism: if a coin trades at ninety-nine cents on an exchange, a trader can buy it cheaply, redeem it with the issuer for a full dollar, and keep the difference, and that buying pressure pushes the price back toward the peg. If it trades above a dollar, the incentive runs the other way. The peg, in other words, holds because breaking it is profitable to fix, as long as redemption genuinely works.
That qualification is the whole lesson. A widely cited explainer puts it directly: a token with sufficient reserves but no functioning redemption process can still depeg, and so can a token with redemption but insufficient reserves. There is also a quieter distinction most guides skip: direct redemption is an issuer relationship, governed by the issuer's terms and account requirements. An ordinary holder who bought on an exchange may, in practice, have only the exchange's market price available at the moment of selling, which is exactly the price that wobbles during a scare. The floor protects most directly those who can actually use it.
Reading a reserve disclosure without fooling yourself
Issuers prove backing with documents, and the documents are not interchangeable. Circle publishes monthly independent attestation reports intended to confirm that dollar-denominated reserves are at least equal to the USDC in circulation, and the reserve fund behind much of it carries daily portfolio reporting. Tether works on a different cadence: in its Q2 2026 attestation, prepared by BDO and reporting figures as of June 30, 2026, the company stated total assets of about US$187.75 billion and said its reserves exceeded its liabilities by approximately US$4.11 billion, with the majority of reserves in U.S. government-backed instruments and short-term liquidity facilities. Those two disclosures answer similar questions on different dates, at different frequencies, with different scopes.
| Check | Why it matters | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Date of the figures | A reserve report is a snapshot, not a live balance | The “as of” date on the report itself, not the date of the web page around it |
| Who checked it | An attestation and an audit are different kinds of assurance | The named firm and the type of engagement described in the document |
| What the reserve holds | Cash and short-term government securities can be sold quickly; less liquid assets may not, in a rush | The asset categories and maturities the issuer lists |
| Separation from the issuer | Reserves mixed with operating money are exposed to the company's other problems | Statements about segregated or separate accounts for reserve assets |
| Who can redeem, and how | The peg's floor only works for holders who can use it | The issuer's current terms for direct redemption eligibility |
None of these rows requires expertise to check. They require only the habit of reading the document rather than the headline about the document, and of refusing to compare two coins by lining up figures from different dates as if they were measured on the same morning.
Crypto-collateralised coins: collateral that must stay ahead of the debt
A second model replaces the bank account with a smart contract. In the Maker protocol, the stablecoin Dai is generated when a user locks collateral worth more than the Dai created into a Vault, over-collateralisation is the buffer that absorbs the collateral's own price swings. Each collateral type carries a Liquidation Ratio set by governance according to its risk profile. If a Vault falls below that ratio and is judged too risky, the protocol liquidates it through automated auctions: the collateral is sold, and the Dai received covers the outstanding debt plus a liquidation penalty.
The strength of this design is transparency, the collateral and the rules are on a public chain. Its weakness is speed. The defence assumes auctions can sell collateral for enough Dai while prices are falling, on the same market that is causing the fall. Over-collateralisation buys room; it does not repeal volatility, and a holder's practical question is always how much room, in the specific collateral, at the specific moment.
Algorithmic designs and the failure pattern
A third family tries to hold a price mainly with supply rules and trading incentives, with little or no hard collateral behind the token. The failure pattern is now well documented in outline. Confidence is the collateral. While holders believe redemption or the supporting mechanism will work, arbitrage defends the price. When that belief cracks, because reserves look thin, because a related asset is falling, because redemption is doubted, selling lowers the price, the lower price weakens belief further, and the mechanism that was supposed to restore the peg instead accelerates away from it. The collapse of TerraUSD in 2022 is the reference case: a large stablecoin that depegged and failed to recover. The lesson is not that code is useless; the arbitrage in a fiat-backed coin is also code-assisted market behaviour. The lesson is that a mechanism without assets behind it has nothing to stand on once belief is the only thing left.
A five-question peg check (the decision framework)
- What, exactly, is in the reserve, and as of what date? Name the asset categories and the snapshot date from the issuer's latest disclosure.
- Who verified it, and in what kind of engagement? Attestation or audit, by whom, covering what period.
- Can a holder like me redeem directly? Read the issuer's terms. If not, the practical exit is an exchange price, and that changes the risk.
- What defends the price on a bad day? Arbitrage against real redemption, liquidation of over-collateral, or incentives alone, in that order of solidity.
- What would I watch for trouble? A widening gap from the peg that does not close, delayed or changed redemption terms, or a disclosure that stops appearing on schedule.
What success looks like: each question has an answer taken from a current, dated issuer document, not from a social post, a listing page, or the coin's own marketing summary. A coin that cannot be described this way has not failed the check; the holder has simply learned that the check cannot yet be passed.
FAQ
Is a stablecoin the same as a dollar in a bank account? No. It is a token issued by a company or a protocol, backed in the ways described above. It carries issuer, reserve, redemption, and technology risks that a bank deposit does not carry in the same form.
Why would a fully backed coin ever trade below its peg? Because the market price and the redemption value are different things. If holders doubt redemption, or cannot access it quickly, they sell at whatever price the market offers, and the gap only closes when arbitrageurs trust the redemption route enough to buy.
Does a reserve attestation guarantee safety? No. An attestation confirms specified figures at a point in time, within the scope of that engagement. It is evidence, and better than no evidence, it is not a promise about next month, or about redemption during a crisis.
Reminder: Crypto Investing is educational content only, not financial advice. Crypto assets are volatile and can lose all value. Product terms, fees, and rules change, read the current prospectus, terms, or manufacturer documentation for any product you are considering.